Comic Review – TMNT #45

Originally written for Flickering Myth.

“The Turtles return from Burnow Island to find unimaginable tragedy. As the family struggles to cope, an enraged Foot Clan prepares its revenge. It’s all been building to this…the start of the final storyline leading to #50!”

 After any huge story it’s reasonable to assume that you’ll need time to decompress. You can’t just keep going hell for leather without processing what happened before or you’ll burn out. It’s tricky though, as you also don’t want to completely put the brakes on and completely deflate the reader; coming down after the excitement can be quite the bummer.
Unfortunately I do feel a bit bummed out after reading #45, and it’s the first time I’ve felt at all let-down by IDW’s take on the TMNT.If you’ve read my reviews before you’ll know I’m pretty glowing about it all, and overall the latest issue still contains the qualities that define the series; amazing artwork from the returning Mateus Santolouco, brought to life by brilliant lettering and colours from stalwarts Shawn Lee and Ronda Pattison, married to well written dialogue from Tom Waltz. We also have several pages served up by returning artist Charles Paul Wilson III, who was impressive on #2 of Turtles in Time. Here it’s a bit less exciting, though no less important and very fitting.

So what am I going on about then? The problem I had is that I read this issue in the same week I read the finale to the latest Batman story, and whilst it shares many similarities it also makes some very different choices; choices that give the decisions made real weight.

I don’t think a hard decision has been ducked, as all the pieces have been in place for some time to take the story in the direction it’s going. But comics are known for letting characters go and bringing them back, so why not use to that to your advantage? Make us believe that actions have true consequences, at least for a few issues. Here we just move straight on, no doubt into the run up to the promised extravaganza that wraps up the current story threads in #50. Maybe in the course of time it will all make sense and I’ll be eating these words. I hope so. Argh, it’s tough to keep non-spoilery sometimes! I try my best.

On the plus side, we do get to see Casey again, and he’s doing what he does best. I was worried he’d gone a bit soft and wasn’t going to get enough attention, so I’m happy on that point.

Right now though I’m perplexed, since I’m deflated due to the fact the story is just charging on. I didn’t think I’d ever be in that situation, and with the way TMNT flows thought I’d be happy with it. But the Northampton storyline juggled the different aspects of reflection and action better I feel.

It’s still a quality comic, and had my bar not been set so high by not only the previous issue but the series overall I’d probably have not been disappointed and let it off. No can do though.


NOTE – I did manage to read the Free Comic Book Day TMNT issue, and if you haven’t it’s OK. With a mix of old and new work you’ll see it all soon anyway. What I did was cool though 🙂

Also this month check out my review for Mutanimals #3 here.

If you enjoyed this why don’t you check out my other reviews and pass it on 🙂

I also have interviews with TMNT artists Ross Campbell and Mateus Santolouco!

You might also want to ‘like’ the Facebook page where I share all my posts along with many other things I think are Super Duper!

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply